Showing posts with label grading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label grading. Show all posts

Saturday, May 09, 2015

Perspective


One thing that really grinds my gears is when students claim that they "didn't have enough time" to finish an assignment.

Our school system policy is to allow students to turn in late work with no penalty to their grade, which, okay, I can accept because according to the standards we are supposed to be evaluating demonstrated academic ability, not behavior. It also helps that we are given (some) flexibility to set harder deadlines, so that we don't receive a metric ton of work at the end of the term from students who are scrambling to pull up their grades.

I think I want my policy to be "once I return an assignment, I will no longer accept it for credit." Ideally I'd post a running tally of how many had originally been turned in and how many I've evaluated so far. Generally, the more work an assignment takes from the student, the more complex it is to evaluate. That would give me more of a sliding scale so that my deadline is both clear and flexible.

Additionally, we allow students to re-assess, so long as they complete a contract identifying problems they encountered and make a plan (usually including additional work for practice) so that when they complete the assessment the second (or third...) time, hopefully they'll do better. But when I see "I didn't have enough time" listed as one of their problems it sends my blood pressure skyrocketing.  Because, see, there was additional time available - I am here before school starts and after it ends. I allow students to come in from any of their other classes to work, so long as they have permission from their other teachers. The library is open before and after school and during the lunch periods.

Did you use any of those opportunities? Did you even ask about them? No? Then don't you dare claim that you "didn't have enough time."


Continue...

Saturday, June 07, 2014

Socialism!


So at the end of the school year we were informed that next year, the lowest grade we would be allowed to put into the computer gradebook, for any assignment, would be a 60. Needless to say, this news caused a bit of a kerfuffle.

My biggest concern is that I don't know of any schools that have used it and found it helpful. If there are some, it sure would be nice to see HOW they implemented it - what other procedures they put in place so that students' grades accurately reflected their demonstrated mastery of the standards.

STICKING POINT: How do we ensure that low-level students do the practice that they need so that they can improve, rather than just taking their 60s and assuming they can do some extra-credit work at the end of the term so that they can move on to the next course (for which they will be unprepared)? Back when I taught 9th grade, we read Lois Lowry's novel 'The Giver.' Scholastic says that it's at a sixth-grade reading level, but some students said that it was too hard for them.

I also think that advanced students will say that this is "unfair," but IMO they need to just suck it up. It is NOT unfair. If they bomb (or blow off!) an assignment, they get the same "free" 60 that everyone else does. And EVERYONE who wants more than a 60 has to work for it. The rules are the same across the board.

It also ties in to the law of diminishing returns, which is primarily an economic concept, but has broader relevance. The better you get at a skill, the harder you have to work in order to improve further, for example. Same idea here. The 60 is free. You want to pass? Gotta work a bit. You want a solid B? Gotta work even harder. You want a really good grade? Better be prepared to study on the weekends!

You can see this in video games, whether it's console shooters or Farmville. When you start off, it's like you CAN'T fail. But as you progress through the game, the content gets harder, and you have to start actually thinking about what you're doing. You may even decide to get help. But that is entirely your choice, you know? If you get frustrated, you can always just stay on a level you're comfortable with and not stress out over trying to beat a level that's too hard for you.

When I spoke with the principal he said that only a few teachers had sent him anything in writing, and that if there were concerns he needed to be able to give some evidence to the higher administrators. But my thought is that the reason that so few teachers have responded is that none of us were given the chance to offer our input before the decision was made. Even IF we hadn't been told that this was definitely going to happen, why wouldn't we be skeptical?

We'll see how it goes.


Continue...

Tuesday, November 01, 2011

Crash & Burn

We're finishing up our Julius Caesar unit and it has been miserable. I know I'm already on record with how much I hate, hate, hate, HATE this play, and how infuriating it is that I'm required by my school to teach it despite having other options that I feel are far superior.

It doesn't help that I'm sick. But with the test tomorrow, of course I dragged myself in today so that we could review. I'm stopped up and dizzy and exhausted and now I'll probably be out for TWO days, instead of just one, but you know what? I really don't care.

And after getting called on the carpet yesterday for not having enough test grades in my gradebook, I started thinking about what exactly constitutes a test, rather than a quiz.

Our calendar was frickin' GUTTED by the state, so now our quarters are eight weeks each instead of nine weeks. And the principal is saying that I should have at least five test grades. By my way of thinking, that's an awful lot - it's about every week and a half or so.

But my units run about four weeks long. So this means I need to shorten them, or else test part way through the unit. I figure one test every other week is about as often as I can manage without feeling like it's just test-test-test.

And I've also been told that ad sales for the publications are now to be done by ME rather than by students. I mean, it's nice to know that they'll be handled accurately, but it's getting to the point that I'm like WTF am I supposed to have them doing?

Image thanks to http://www.gamereality.org/peliarvostelut/xbox_crashnburn.html


Continue...

Thursday, April 21, 2011

Tired of it

Sometimes I feel like such a fraud. *sigh*

I really don't enjoy reading the stuff my students write. Or, well, at least not most of it. It's just... gosh, I'm not even sure how to explain all of this. There are so many things that bother me about their writing that I'm often not sure where to begin when responding, let alone where I should begin with this blog post.

First of all, the topics. I get SOOO tired of reading about teen pregnancy or drugs or tattoos/piercings/dress code/fashion or favorite XYZ or Bigfoot ...

Seriously, why are teen pregnancy and teen alcoholism and teen drug use even ON the List of Acceptable Topics for a persuasive essay? They glom onto the idea that "teen drug use is bad" and want to use that for a thesis. UGH. Really? Really? You honest-to-goodness think you have to persuade ANYONE of that? GAWD.

So I get tired of the same old topics but those are the ones we're stuck with because that's what we have books on in the library. Hate, hate, hatey-hatesmith. Pouring on the Haterade.

And then they're soooo wishy-washy. Like the student who wrote about tattoos CLEARLY believed that people should be able to do whatever they want to their own bodies without being judged (negatively) for their appearance, BUT she also felt she had to say "but some people think tattoos are bad and that's okay too!" FFS, kids, it is not immoral to have a spine! GAWD.

Also apparently? the entire universe is about what is most pleasant for THEM. Like we should totes allow indiscriminate cell phone use. Except cheating would be bad. And also? Dress code, shmess code. Students should be able to hoochify if they like because that is SELF EXPRESSION and we are CRUSHING THEIR INDIVIDUALITY.

I find that I am enjoying this more the snarkier I get about it...

And then there is the grammar. We're not just talking fragments and run-ons here -- oh no. No, these sentences are so warped that I can't even begin to describe what's wrong with them. Some recent gems, grabbed from a cursory scan of what is supposed to be a re-revision of a typed final:

  • Is it because they are jealous, I think so?
  • these are the things we think about at first had but when we are stranded in the middle of the ocean we tend to think of things we never think to think of at first hand.
  • To these age groups, school, for lack of a better word to say it, SUCKS.
  • They can ruin their potential to have a great life, though some teenage mothers go back to school and have a great life while having a child others do not and that's because having a baby is a lot of work, feedings every two hours, changing constantly, keeping you up all night...etc, having a baby isn't easy, it's a very stressful job.
  • The big fight is Facebook vs. Myspace.Ok, that one's not as bad... but the image makes me giggle.
  • At a young age 15-19 some teens are not even mature enough to have sex, because they're not laying down thinking about what could happen for example becoming pregnant, at that moment all the teenager has on his/her mind is the sex and only sex!
  • Being abstinent is hard for many people, but being careful means more than just having sex, and not being cautious.
  • At least you know you tried to stop the prevention of being pregnant.(WTF?!)
  • Everyone has opinions, Walker least appetizing meal choice was the roast beef and cheese sub, he said it looked "Greasy".

I'm not even halfway through the stack. :P

Keep in mind, this is after a rough draft, conferencing with me for direction, revision, printing a new draft, peer revisions, proofreading, and printing a final draft. THEN. Another conference with me to look over the three articles for which they did that, choosing the best of those three, and RE-re-tooling it.

*headdesk*

This is yet another reason I will NOT be teaching Journalism next year.

Image thanks to https://picasaweb.google.com/Just4Me.Diamond/


Continue...

Friday, July 16, 2010

I Got Furious - Fast!

This made me soooo mad. Mad enough to snark, folks. I'm gonna cross-post my response behind the cut, because to be quite honest, I'm not entirely sure it's ever going to make it past the moderators of the original article!

Perhaps you need to make the time.

Seriously? Since when are teachers the ones who determine their work schedules?

Let’s be generous and say we take just FIFTEEN MINUTES to grade each ten-page paper. With a courseload of 175 students, which is quite reasonable, that’s 43 hours, 45 minutes of actual grading time.

Let’s say teachers get an hour every day for planning (most have less, but it makes the arithmetic easier). Now we don’t want to stop teaching just because we’ve got all these papers to grade, so let’s set aside half of it for continued planning and OTHER grading. That means that given the time teachers are allotted, it would take 98 days to finish grading that ONE assignment.

But wait! I hear you cry. Teachers aren’t supposed to have families, or doctor appointments, or friends, or religious services, or household chores. Teachers should dedicate their ENTIRE BEING to their work, because it’s not a career, it’s a calling!

Ugh. What utter claptrap.

The time that we spend grading research papers is time that can NOT be used to create new resources or lessons for our students, time that can NOT be used to respond in greater detail to shorter assignments, time that can NOT be used to learn about new instructional or management techniques, or about new technologies and how to incorporate them to improve student achievement.

Then again, it’s also time in which we’re not subjected to nonsense from self-righteous idiots. Definitely a plus.

I actually held back a good bit, because (a) responding to idiocy with idiocy just increases the amount of idiocy out there, and I don't want that, and (b) because I think I actually have a point, and I want others to hear it, and having the comment not get posted because it was too snarky limits its audience.

But I'm just not sure. I kind of feel like Clay the Clueless deserved a good bit more than what I gave him. Maybe I was a little bit too gentle...

What do you think?

Image thanks to http://www.pureanimegallery.com/


Continue...

Monday, September 21, 2009

Today is a GOOD day

After spending all weekend slaving over those darn research papers (except for the time I spent on here grousing about attempting to write a donorschoose essay) I finally got done last night. I still have to check cards and outlines, but that's pretty much a completion grade - making sure there aren't any that are just duplicates and/or "This is a fact card for my research paper" cards.

And I did get TWO new donorschoose proposals written - they're under review now.

And THEN sometime last night (I crashed at, like, eight) the Hunk nudged me awake enough to tell me that the roads were washed out and SCHOOL IS CLOSED TODAY.

!!!!!

Seriously?! I mean, because, ALL WEEK it was rolling around in my brain that I was going to have no weekend thanks to those papers. I've been grinding through them as best as I can but GRACIOUS it's awful. As in why are there no citations anywhere in your paper?? WTF?!

And now I get a day for ME. I just feel so ... so vindicated! I am going to play WoW, and read Fire Study (I am SO glad we picked that up last night), and ... well, okay, and I'll probably work on my next two unit plans. Where is my copy of Shakespeare Set Free?...

Granted, if it doesn't stop raining sometime today, there may be serious trouble. Right now it's just flooded roads and possibly some power outages, afaik.

(Tangent: I've started pronouncing web acronyms as words. So, like: btw = BIT-oo, wtf = wa-ta-FAY, afaik = uh-FAKE. Usually lowercased like regular words, BUT, if they're at the start of a sentences, the whole thing gets uppercased. Why? Because! I don't know!)

Ennyhoo, WE at least will be all right. Temperatures are quite mild, and being stuck in the house with neither power nor water would be quite feasible, if inconvenient, for up to a week - perhaps longer. But I REALLY don't think it'll go even that far.

And then! This morning I got an email that said that my latest donorschoose proposal has been funded! We're getting two new digital cameras! WAHOOO!

Just a coupla point-and-shoots, but still! ^.^ Glee!

LIFE IS GOOD! *happysigh*


Continue...

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

ARGH.

JMJ. I am honest-to-God sick of students asking me if I've graded their crap. Especially when they turned in research papers to a sub while I was away at the GCTE conference and they ask me the DAY I GET BACK. Um, hello, I just got the folders out of my mailbox thirty minutes ago?

There is a related discussion over at the English Companion ning. The consensus seems to be that specific feedback is much more useful/helpful/taken seriously by the students than a grade. Give feedback regularly, and grade only the final draft.

WTF? Where are these students and how do I get some? Because if they have the slightest INKLING that an assignment isn't going to be graded, they don't do it.

It just feels like this is the way we're supposed to do things because it works - yeah - it works for everyone EXCEPT ME. I'm sick of it. I'm tired of being confused and feeling helpless and incompetent.

Maybe it's because we're smack in the middle of February and I'm not going to get a break until April. I dunno. But I'm getting really annoyed at having to answer the same brainless questions over and over again. You know how they say "there are no stupid questions?" They're right.

It's not the QUESTIONS that are the problem. It's the people askin' em. ;p

Image thanks to www.t-shirthumor.com


Continue...

Monday, January 05, 2009

Made it... so far

So I just finished getting my grades in .. technically they're not DUE until 4 tomorrow, but I just put things off so damn long. UGH. What is WRONG with me? I mean, I pretty much had to spend this weekend grading. I could've done this the weekend before Christmas and then been free & clear all break!

Well. Except for the Damn Book... which I'm incredibly behind on. I don't even want to think about that.

I hope to goodness I'll be able to work on that tomorrow. Ugh.

Image thanks to http://flickr.com/photos/lausanne/787931134/


Continue...

Thursday, January 01, 2009

It is ten past two in the afternoon

... and I still have not finished the grading that I intended to have completed last week.

EFF.


Continue...

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

Stuck in the Car

So we're in the car. Still. I'm sick of Virginia and there's like an hour and a half left to go. And since we're in the car, I can't surf the net - though there hasn't been a whole lot of activity lately. (BTW - I wrote this on Saturday, 12/27, but I haven't had a way to upload it until we got back home.)

Talked with the Hunk about moving to Denver, though that isn't really all that likely. It just sounds like up in that neck of the woods they're doing some really interesting things - optional merit pay and true standards-based teaching. And the pay is better.

Not that I don't like where I am; Coach has been encouraging us to start considering standards-based grading, and our grade team was assigned Understanding by Design as a professional development book, so I definitely approve of the administration's choices as far as curriculum and instruction go. I'd just like to make sure that if we do make a go of it, it's with enough planning and support to have a chance at success, otherwise, why bother putting forth any effort at all?

At our last department meeting, Coach brought up SBG and mentioned (one) that in some schools, teachers don't give any grades lower than a 50, which brought up a heated discussion about how much - or whether! - effort should count in a student's grade, as well as WHY a zero is mathematically unsound (Coach mentioned this, but I got a chance to sound real smart by explaining what I've learned from all of you lovely people about the difference between the 0-4 scale and the 0-100 scale). This then brought up the question, "what do we do when a student doesn't produce enough work to demonstrate mastery of some of the standards?" Sure, as professionals, we can document conversations and other less formal in-class activity as a way to assess student progress, but I'm incredibly uncomfortable with the idea of using that as a way to justify mastery (or lack thereof). I can just see that leading to "well, I think she can do it, so..."

I hope it wasn't too direct of me to say that I was all for SBG as long as the administration would back us up when we didn't promote students who had, say, a 75 average but had several assessments they hadn't bothered to complete.

Coach also fished out the overworked "parachute packing class" metaphor (can't we come up with something better? it's so darn flimsy, too!) and suggested we think about how important it is for a student to demonstrate mastery of a standard at the same time as his classmates. If when it's first assessed, the student shows limited mastery, but later on, through additional practice or further instruction or whatever, demonstrates a more complete understanding, should the earlier grades still count against him? I said again, great theory, but let's look at the practical considerations. We're told that once a marking period ends and we turn those grades in, they are FINAL. What happens if a student makes great strides during the next marking period? Do we go back and change the grades from the earlier marking period and then ask the administrators to make the changes to the permanent grade?

I just really hope that I'm not coming across as a wet blanket. These are strategies that I like! I want us to start using them. I just want us to be able to use them effectively.

And I'm relying on italics again. Siiiiigh.

Images thanks to http://literaldan.blogspot.com/ and http://www.womensmemorial.org/H&C/Collections/pararig.html


Continue...

Monday, November 10, 2008

Test Anxiety

I am SO incredibly nervous.

Since the students did SO poorly on the fact-recall quiz for Julius Caesar, we reviewed pretty extensively before taking the final test.

It focuses much more on identifying techniques (different types of figurative language, monologue vs. soliloquy, etc.) and identifying cause-and-effect and motivation. It isn't longer - but it's harder. But it covers skills and concepts that align with our standards.

I don't want them to flunk, but based on their lackadaisical participation during the review, I can't imagine they'll do well. And I don't know that there's anything more that I can - or should - do.

I can't just pass them on if they haven't earned it by demonstrating that they've learned the required material. But it's not going to look good if I've got a 30% pass rate, either.

Ugh.


Continue...

Friday, October 17, 2008

All right, all right!

I admit it. I'm procrastinating.

Ugh. I've been on top of things ALL WEEK, and now it's Friday, and I've got two assignments to hand back in first period, and I haven't responded to them. Plus I haven't written the pop quiz they're supposed to take.

It's times like this that I do wonder why I don't just march through the lit book and the supplemental materials. :P

It's the freewriting that's got me stuck. I've responded to three sets and I've got one more (the other assignment will go quickly). And... I just feel like I'm not responding intelligently anymore. Like there are these pat responses: "this is confusing," "this is interesting but it doesn't seem to fit with the rest of what you're saying," "neat idea - can you think of examples to use for support," and so on.

How do you give unique, individualized responses to 100+ journal-like-things? Can it be done?


Continue...

Saturday, August 09, 2008

Streeeetch!

Whew! What a day. I woke up at 5, and then again at 6:30 and couldn't get back to sleep, so I got up and started grading and entering. Twelve and a half hours later, I'm finally done.

Not including a break to help my parents load their van and head out, and another for a lovely three-hour nap, I've been grading ALL. FRIKKIN. DAY.

On the up side of things, I'm completely caught up except for a memorization quiz that The Hunk promised he'd check for me, so Imonna let him! Then I'll have to enter those grades, and that'll be all.

We just made the unfinished bedroom into a habitable space and I'm going to be using that as my office, so I think now I'm going to get my stuff together and set that space up. Then this evening I'll try to plan out next week in Journalism and the King Arthur unit for English II. I have some ideas for where I'm going with that, but I need to look over those ideas again while I've also got my hands on the materials I currently have. I hope I can make it work the way I'm thinking.

Melissa, I swear I've got a TALT in the back of my head - two, actually, now, after last night, but I'm keeping them both under wraps! I hope to type one of 'em up this evening.


Continue...

Friday, August 08, 2008

Woohoo!

So last night I found out how to make several hours of grading a good bit more enjoyable.

While it was lovely to have company and sympathy from The Hunk, I think the two Long Island Iced Teas may have had more to do with it.

Woohoo!


Image thanks to http://aliedwards.typepad.com/_a_/just_good_stuff/index.html


Continue...

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Woot!

First block has started posting their Odyssey projects to the class blog. I want SO BADLY to brag on them to EVERYBODY, but after wikispaces and pbwiki were blocked after we tried to use them last semester I'm kind of afraid to... at least until all the projects are uploaded! ^.^

Now here's my request. I've had to DRAG this work out of some of them - and not because they're unwilling to work (well, not entirely). A number of students have been honestly struggling with this. The handout I gave them is included below.



Odyssey Project – Create a class Wiki


A wiki is a “mini-internet” of web pages that are linked to each other. One of the best known wikis is Wikipedia. Your project work will help complete a class wiki about The Odyssey, by Homer.

Each of you will focus on a different book or a different character. You will need to create content for your page BEFORE we go to the computer lab, because we will have a limited amount of time in the lab. At the end of the day in the computer lab, you should print out your page and hand it in so that Mrs. Cole can see how much progress you have made.

Your wiki project will need a title and the following sections:

Section 1 – “About the author.”
Introduce yourself to the reader. What are some things you’re good at? What do you like to do in your free time? What careers interest you? What makes you unique? 50-75 words (only 4+ letters count).
No last names (last initials are acceptable) or town names.

Section 2 – Your project work
Include all the information necessary, according to the project category you were assigned.
Check to make sure that links work and pictures are visible.

Section 3 – What you learned from reading The Odyssey and working on the project
Go back to your “Need to Learn” notes (or the “Georgia Performance Standards” handout) to review a list of skills and information.
Explain what you learned and how you learned it.
40-60 words (only 4+ letters count).

*Each section should be labeled with a heading (Section 1, Section 2, or Section 3) and separated from the others by a horizontal line.

Project Categories:
A. A summary (250 words+) of the book you are assigned. Be specific. Use your own words, but give examples from the story. Answer the following questions:
1. Where did Odysseus go?
2. What did he find there?
3. What problems did he face?
4. What did he do about it?
5. What was the outcome?
B. A character page. - 5 characters from the story, as assigned. Each character should have a brief (50-word+) biography.
- What type of personality does this character have, and how do you know?
- What does this character do that affects the events of the story?
- Working links to different web pages for each character. Include a brief description of what is on each page (total of 20 links – you don’t have to have the same number of links for each character).
C. A comparison (250 words+) between the fictional character you are assigned and real-life history. This will require research on your part. What would life really have been like for a person like your character?
- What was life like for a person of that age?
- What was life like for a person of that gender?
- What was life like for a person of that class?
- What was life like for a person of that occupation?
D. A story, drama, or interview (250 words+) involving the character you are assigned confronting the author about how his/her portrayal was handled in the story.
- Was the character portrayed favorably?
- Why or why not?
- Which character provides the point of view in that part of the story?
- Why might Homer have chosen to show things as he did?
- What motivation might the character have had for his/her actions?
E. A book review (250+ words) in which you judge the story as entertainment and historical reference.
- Is The Odyssey a fun story? Why or why not? Give specific examples from the story that support your answer, and explain how they support your point.
- Is The Odyssey historically accurate? Why or why not? What can we learn about the way people lived in ancient times?

Bonus
All projects completed: +3
All projects completed on time: +10


Continue...

Thursday, April 10, 2008

Ooo, I'm steamed.

What cheek! What absolute cheek. Yesterday I got a note from one of my little "angels" in last period. A couple things to note:

1) It is REALLY hot. I think it gets above 85 (F) in there. I'm pretty sure my thermostat is set to heat, so the air doesn't kick in at all. And it's jammed closed.
2)NOTHING seems to work with this class. There aren't outbursts that are dangerous, and for the most part they're not openly defiant, but they don't pay attention, they speak out of turn ALL THE TIME, they get distracted VERY easily (and they're very willing to distract others), and redirects/reminders last for like 15 seconds.
At any rate, one student wasn't happy about the situation, and she took the time (rather than, God forbid, WORKING) to let me know. I'm a little bit pleased that she wrote the note rather than just mouthing off. There's that, at least. So here's what it said:

Dear Mrs. (Clix),

I just wanted you to know that it wont hurt you any to lighten up a little bit. People do stuff to make you made because it dont take much to get you upset and start screaming. I cant stand that, when im In your class it feels like im in Jail. And it is so hot in here its like an oven, but that dont bother you either because you only care about yourself. Im not being smart in anyway but you wont listen so I have to write it and it still does no good. You have very little Patience and thats something you need to be able to teach good. This year to be honest i havent learned much from you, because you throw stuff on us that you Probably dont fully understand. Im Just asking you to treat your students as if you would if you had A child. Because you wouldnt want to treat your child bad. Well thats all i have to say. Maybe you will relize what im saynig is true.

(Student name - with a HEART by it! WTF?)

Obviously, I need to focus more on apostrophe use... >;)

On a less snarky note, I am asking her to stop by my class at the end of this period. I'd like to take this seriously and model the behavior that I would like to see from her.

But ooooo! It gets my back up. ;p

On the plus side, it looks like my first period class today is breezing through the essay exam for The Odyssey. I'm gonna go ahead and read through some of them... fingers crossed...


Continue...

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Nine PM ALREADY?!

Ugh. I still have more grading to do, darnit!

I've started going over reading strategies with my freshmen. We read Asimov's "The Fun They Had," and for most of them it took 10-15 minutes (charting as they went). Some of them actually had the GALL to gripe about the length of the story! It's not even a thousand words!!

Heavens. What're they gonna do when I dump them into something that's actually AT GRADE LEVEL, like "To Build a Fire" (7176 words) or "The Most Dangerous Game" (8426)? Granted, we've also got Poe's "The Cask of Amontillado" (2495) in the anthology as well, but I hardly think that's any easier, what with the archaic language and all...


Continue...

Thursday, December 13, 2007

Exhaustion

It is 7:26 and I am ready to crash for the night.

Thank GOD tomorrow is Friday, and it will effectively be the last day of the semester. Monday and Tuesday are standardized testing, and Wednesday is a half-day; the only class I'll have is Journalism, because I've got planning early. (Never mind that our upcoming yearbook deadline has smashed me up against a brick wall in a hammerlock and demanded my lunch money. That's what Saturday is for. *sigh*)

I'm dumbing down my instruction worksheets. I hate using the same word over and over, but I am learning that repeatedly defining the same word over and over is even WORSE. GRH. "Key" and "significant" are now "important." "Passages" has become "sections." "Plausible" will be replaced with "believable." I don't know what I'm going to do about "psychological."

I hope I can remember to write up a bunch of limericks for our poetry unit for next semester. I want to use them to teach meter, because as much as different dictionaries are claiming it is anapestic, it totally doesn't have to be. You just need five lines, an AABBA rhyme scheme, and a corresponding 3/3/2/2/3 feet per line. I don't know how to make the difference between accented and unaccented syllables click for them if they don't already understand that. I'm hoping limericks will help.

As I write this (and dumb down my instructions, but - HA HA HA, you little pishers - NOT the work itself) my wonderful pie is cooling. 50 minutes more and it will be cool enough to cut without turning it into cobbler. (Maybe.) In a little more than an hour, I will be abed.


Continue...

Friday, December 07, 2007

Apples, oranges, and zeros

This isn't from Hugh's original post, but from his response to one of the comments.

Your insistence that a zero is valid in a percentile frame of reference is to say that you can add an orange to a collection of apples, and still arrive at an apple that is a pure indicator of the collection of apples. ("Orange" being a zero given for late or missing work.) How do you do that?

Come to the grocery store with me...

In the produce section of most grocery stores, you can buy apples by the bag. Let's say you see a bag of apples that are particularly nice. They don't have any that are puny or look green and you don't spot any bruises. So you pick up that bag and as you do, you notice that it seems kind of loose. You pick up another bag and it is heavier! Factory error, naughty shopper, whatever the reason, the first bag is short an apple. Doesn't that matter?!

Zeros are not oranges. They're apples that are missing.

if they actually do score a zero on a test (not because they are absent) but because their answers are not correct, or they don’t provide any answers at all, that should not be represented in the mean score over the term?

With regard to your hypothetical case of the student actually scoring zero…you cannot escape the fact that the mean is ruined by extreme scores. You might consider using the median average, which is less affected by outliers.

In this case, the apple isn't missing. It's just... squishy. The question: how much does that one squishy apple affect the value of the bag?

My answer: a stinkin' LOT!

About five percent of my undergrad and graduate profs practiced their craft in the same way, and they were revered by their students. The others “profs” who practiced “real world” grading and lectured to sleeping students were merely tolerated as a means to an end…the sheepskin.

Well... YEAH! I mean, I'd love it too if I could focus just on doing a bang-up job on my lesson planning, grade nothing, and earn merit pay for being a wonderful teacher because all I submit are my wonderful lesson plans!

But that's not how it works. Students who don't turn in major assignments have big gaping holes in their overall grade that reflect the big gaping holes in their proof of competence. Maybe they understand the material - but I have no proof.

The more I read about this issue and ponder it, the more I am in favor of giving a zero when there is zero work done, but allowing students as much opportunity as they need to demonstrate competence, until the decision is no longer mine to make after the term ends.


Continue...

More on Zeros

As I continue to reflect, I think I am going to keep my zeros. I may see if I can't find a way to make zeros on homework grades less damaging, because I do agree with the formative/summative divide - that is, that it isn't right or helpful to grade a student's work when they're practicing and we don't even expect them to have learned it!

I posted this over on RepairKit:

I think we disagree on our understanding of what a cumulative grade represents. IMO, it is not simply a measure of the quality of a student's work (in which case I would agree with you); it should represent the quality of a student's work in relation to the standards. Unless each assessment covers ALL the standards, a student who has turned in all summative assessments and done well on them SHOULD have a better grade than a student who has turned in half of the assessments and done very well on them. Otherwise you are simply taking on faith the student's ability to do well on the uncompleted (and therefore unproven) work, and that's not fair either.

On tests, do you excuse answers that are not completed? How far do you think this should be taken?


If I excuse uncompleted summative assessments, it would be conceivable that a student could pass by demonstrating competence on some standards and hiding from the other tests! I mean, a student who is smart but doesn't want to work (haven't we all known them?!) could get away with learning absolutely nothing at all. Just prove your current proficiency and don't turn in anything else, yanno?

The Science Goddess has suggested marking Incompletes in the gradebook (and SG, I am SO sorry - I can't find where you said that, please forgive [and correct! :D] me if I misrepresent your position); a student who had "enough" Incompletes would not get credit for the course.

Ok, first of all, I reeeeally don't want to get into what constitutes "enough" to mark failure. Second, as a student... I dunno, maybe I was just well-indoctrinated? I would look at my grades, see all those Is, and then go, "Oh look! I've got an 85! Wow, I thought it'd be much lower!"

I mean, it sounds to me that if a student who gets a bunch of Incompletes fails the course, they work the same way as zeros, except that they don't show up in the numeric grade. Now, if your district/school/administration/WHOEVER is already moving away from the illusion of "objective" grading, then maybe you can do this. Me? I'm just... it's me. All by my lonesome. I am "the voice crying out in the wilderness," I guess... although I'm not quite that weird. (Honey, mm, yes please, but I'll pass on the locusts, thanks!) Oh, AND I don't have tenure.

So, for now, I will keep the zeros. I will continue to work to make sure my summative assessments are standards-aligned, so that I can pinpoint which standards students are struggling with and give help on those while allowing them to polish and improve work for standards they have mastered.

It's just so hard.

(Note to self: It is OKAY that you're not brilliant yet. You are still a babe in them thar woods. But one day... *shakes fist at sky* ...one day...)


Continue...